After Parul Khakar, now another Gujarati rises to ask whether India is a Democracy or an authoritarian State

| Updated: August 3, 2022 1:28 pm

When Pankti Jog, a resident of Ahmedabad asked the local police as to whether we lived in an authoritarian or feudal State and whether Ministers were Kings that the Praja (the citizens) had to live under their diktats and not democratic principles, she meant it. Literally.

Local police in Gujarat in Ahmedabad, issued instructions to about 300 residents to keep all their doors and windows in their homes closed for three hours. But it took one woman, Pankti who for very valid reasons raised the question.

The police circular issued by Vejalpur police station read, “very obediently we would like to inform that respected Home Minister of India Shri Amit Shah is visiting this area to inaugurate a community hall on Sunday. Since he belongs to Z security, his security is important so on Sunday July 11, 2021, please keep all your doors and windows of your apartments or other homes, closed from 10 am to 1 pm”. The circular was issued by Police inspector of Vejalpur, L D Odedara.

Inspector L D Odedara, Vejalpur Police station

The police served the notice to residents of at least five apartments Swaminarayan Park Society, Swati Apartments and others. About 300 residents had to keep their doors and windows closed in the middle class locality. The notice was served to these apartments on July 10.

Vibes of India confirmed that there were no such instructions from Amit Shah’s security team.  Amit Shah’s security team is of 55 personnel including ten National Security Commandoes.

Home Minister Amit Shah inaugurating the community hall, Vejalpur on July 11

Amit Shah is in Ahmedabad for two days. On Sunday, he inaugurated over ten programmes, and  foundation stone laying services, for APMC, aanganwadis and smart classrooms. Gujarat goes to polls in December 2021. His inaugurations yesterday included a library, a civic centre, a water distribution projects besides this community hall inauguration at Vejalpur.

Home Minister Amit Shah in Ahmedabad

By the time you read this story, Amit Shah, as per his schedule would have attended the Mangala aarti of Lord Jagannath at 4 am on Monday. This is an annual  ritual that Amit Shah tries to stick by since decades.

After the Vejalpur police issued the circular to different societies, chairmen and secretaries of these society ensured that the request was strictly followed. And this petrified Pankti, a 44-year-old lady living on the third floor of A block of an apartment in Vejalpur. 

She has asthma since childhood and no fresh air hurts her lungs badly and gives her asthma attacks. So, she went to the Vejalpur police station to inquire whether “we live in a democracy or are Ministers still the Kings”.

When Vibes of India contacted PI LD Odedra, Vejalpur police station he said, “We requested the residents, we did not force them. The request to keep the doors and windows closed was made so that the slightest movement near the inauguration site could be noticed. The buildings were adjacent to the community hall and that’s why we had to take precautions”.

Pankti, a RTI activist who is proud Goan-Gujarati sent an email to Police Commissioner Office, Shahibaug regarding this and they eventually acted upon it. She also took to Facebook and wrote.

Everyone has accepted has he invisible rule of keeping their doors and windows close when a politician is passing through an area. But there is no such rule in the Z plus security protocol. Police tells us something authoritatively and we believe it.

Today the Vejalpur police has clarified that they have just requested and not ordered us. The question is not about keeping the windows opened for two hours. But why should the Government decide how I live in my own house. Asserting that we live in a democracy and not an authoritative or feudal State, she wrote:

“Today the Government will tell me to keep my windows closed. Why should the Government decide this? Today it is windows, tomorrow this government will decide what I eat and where I go”, she asked.

She also wrote: 

“Another important point is that a MP, MLA, Minister is not a God. They are the ten-headed demons we read about in Puranas. There is no need that we fear them and completely surrender to them. They are public servants, public representatives. They have to answer the people. They are bound to answer us. 

If all the poor people selling vegetables and other things would have unitedly raised this issue, they wouldn’t have had to keep their small businesses shut for three consecutive days.

More fearsome than government rules, or pressure from political workers , more fearsome, worrying and bad is that we fear, we listen to authorities meekly and we do not raise questions.

Around 1500 vendors work in the Vejalpur area and all of them had to shut their work for three days. Who will compensate for their loss? It is a known trend of the government to attack citizens’ freedom through their protocols,” Jog told Vibes of India on Sunday night.

Vibes of India reached out to Ahmedabad Police Commissioner Sanjay Srivastav who lashed out at the local police who issued this circular. Inspector Odedara is a senior and experienced police personnel and it wasn’t expected of him to indulge in this act. Necessary action will be taken against him”, he assured Vibes of India.

Ahmedabad City Police Commissioner Sanjay Srivastav


Senior Congress leader Arjun Modhwadia said, “It is the responsibility of political leaders to create convenience for people, solve their problems and not add to it. If politicians feel unsafe in a public place they should avoid their frequent visits to inaugurate places. The community hall can operate even if it is not inaugurated by the Home Minister,” he also highlighted this inappropriate behaviour  of politicians a few weeks back when a 50-year-old woman died of post-Covid complications in Uttar Pradesh’s Kanpur after the car ferrying her to the hospital was stuck in traffic during President Ram Nath Kovind’s visit to the city.

Arjun Modhwadia

However, the BJP denied the incident and appeared aloof about the Police Commissioner’s statement of initiating action against Inspector Odedara. In fact, the Gujarat BJP dubbed this as a normal practise.

“It is the prerogative of the security forces to safeguard our Home Minister. And irrespective of the person the security services have been practicing in a similar fashion for the past 30-40 years.  It’s a normal practice.  Even during Rath yatra, people are asked to keep their doors and windows shut and it is for their safety. As a civilian, I would abide by the rules and would expect the same from others,” Yamal Vyas, chief spokesperson, BJP, Gujarat said.

Yamal Vyas

Regarding Jog’s concerns, he added, “She could have communicated her concerns to the police and as her problem is genuine; I’m sure police would have given her leeway.” 

The question she posed was, “Till when shall we have to go to plead for our basic freedom”.

 Pankti Jog also posted the following poem

Along with the post she posted a famous poem by late Punjabi poet Avtar Singh Sandhu aka Pash. It reads:

सबसे खतरनाक होता है

मुर्दा शांति से भर जाना

तड़प का न होना सब सहन कर जाना

घर से निकलना काम पर

और काम से लौटकर घर जाना

सबसे खतरनाक होता है

हमारे सपनों का मर जाना

To be buried under the silence is undoubtedly miserable,

But it is still not the most dangerous.

To remain silent in the noise of corruption is undoubtedly miserable,

Reading covertly under the light of a firefly is undoubtedly miserable,

But it is still not the most dangerous.

The most dangerous deed is to be filled with dead silence,

Getting trapped in the routine of running from home to work and from work to home,

The most dangerous accident is the death of our dreams.

Post a Comments

3 Comments

  1. Mukesh Prasad

    This protocol is age old, nothing new has happened. I still remember how we were badly treated by the security in Delhi when Rajiv Gandhi was to pass by the road. Me and my wife were waiting at a petrol pump which was a pickup point for Rajasthan Tourism bus, as we had booked a ticket for travelling to Jaipur. We were soon told by the security, to go behind the petrol pump and stand facing away from the road. We said that our bus is to arrive soon and we shall board that. But what can you do when the security fellow aims his stengun to you. So we walked back several yards turning my head half towards the road to see my incoming bus. It came as scheduled. No sooner we ran towards our bus, two security persons pointed their gun at the driver. The bus started moving slowly. I ran towards the bus to board and my wife who was not as swift as me followed few yards behind. To make the bus stop for a few seconds I boarded the bus to request the driver to pause the bus for a few seconds. The security guy shoved his gun in the driver’s neck. The poor fellow started moving the bus swiftly, the helper refusing to open the door for fear of the security and my wife running the race of her life to catch the bus. She was absolutely new to Delhi, and I was unable to either pick her up or myself get down. She ran almost 300-400 mts, when the driver finally acceeded to my shouts and stopped the bus suddenly. I managed to pull my wife inside. We sat on our seats. But because of this sudden and extrme physical demand on her body, she started vomiting. I tried to manage the situation, but she continued to vomit several times on the way. We reached Jaipur, stayed in a hotel room for two days, not once stepping outside because of her upset health and returned back to Delhi.

    That very day I had cursed Rajiv Gandhi for treating the people of the country as minions and just think about their own comfort and security. I felt sad when he died, but recalled my curse of that day. I think there is Karma at work always in life.

    So this happening in Amit Shah’s tour is no big deal. This has always been like it.

Your email address will not be published.