A proposed land allotment to former Indian cricketer and Lok Sabha MP Yusuf Pathan in Vadodara has raised questions over how public land is being given to an individual. A citizens’ group has now approached the Gujarat government and the Vadodara Municipal Corporation (VMC), demanding that the decision be withdrawn.
The controversy concerns a 978-square-metre plot in the Tandalja area, estimated to be worth Rs 20.53 crore. Under the proposed arrangement, 500 square metres of land will be given to Pathan free of cost, while the remaining 478 square metres will be allotted at 55% of its assessed value. This means a 45% concession on the price of the remaining land.
The issue is expected to come up at the VMC General Board meeting scheduled for November 18, where the members will consider the proposal already approved by the Standing Committee.
Vishwamitri Bachao Samiti, a citizens’ group, has objected to the proposed allotment and questioned why public land worth nearly Rs 20 crore is being transferred to an individual without a public auction.
Two days before the General Board meeting, the group submitted a written representation to the Additional Chief Secretary of the Urban Development and Urban Housing Department and the Vadodara Municipal Commissioner.
The group has argued that the proposed allotment does not follow the Gujarat government’s rules for the disposal of public land. It has also questioned how an individual can receive land under the special-case provisions of the regulations.
Advocate Amin, who raised objections on behalf of the group, pointed to the Gujarat Urban/Area Development Authorities (Disposal of Land and Other Properties) Regulations, 2002.
According to the group, Regulation 13 identifies certain institutions, charitable trusts, educational and research bodies, and religious trusts as eligible for special allotments. It has questioned how these provisions can be used to allot land to an individual.
The group has also asked why the land was not offered through a public auction, tender or open bidding process.
According to the VMC’s approved valuation of Rs 2.10 lakh per square metre, the total estimated value of the 978-square-metre plot is around Rs 20.53 crore.
Under the Gujarat government’s proposal, the land will be divided into two parts:
500 square metres: To be given to Yusuf Pathan free of cost for residential use.
478 square metres: To be transferred at 55% of its assessed value, giving him a 45% concession.
The government resolution also states that the state Revenue Department will provide the VMC with land equivalent in value to the portion being transferred. It further says that this decision should not be treated as an example for similar allotments in the future.
However, the citizens’ group wants the government to explain the reasons behind this special arrangement and disclose the legal basis for it.
How Did The Dispute Begin In 2012?
The land dispute is not new. It dates back to 2012, when Pathan approached the VMC seeking a 99-year lease of the open plot next to his family’s residence in Tandalja.
At the time, he cited security concerns and the convenience of having the adjoining land for residential use.
Initially, the VMC’s Standing Committee and General Board approved the proposal. However, the allotment required the state government’s approval.
On June 9, 2014, the Gujarat government’s Urban Development Department rejected the proposal, stating that the land should be allotted through a public auction or open bidding process.
Following the rejection, the VMC alleged that Pathan had put up a boundary around the plot and occupied it without permission.
The matter took another turn in June 2024, when Pathan was elected to the Lok Sabha from Baharampur in West Bengal on a Trinamool Congress (TMC) ticket.
Soon after his election, the VMC issued him a notice asking him to remove the alleged encroachment from the land.
Pathan challenged the notice in the Gujarat High Court. However, in August 2025, the court upheld the government’s earlier decision to reject his land allotment request.
The court observed that simply occupying a piece of land for a long period does not give a person legal ownership or rights over it when there is no formal allotment order or payment.
Pathan later challenged this decision before a division bench of the High Court. However, on August 31, 2026, he withdrew his appeal without conditions.
With the Gujarat government now approving the fresh allotment proposal and the VMC Standing Committee clearing it, the Vishwamitri Bachao Samiti has sought answers from the authorities.
The group has demanded that the government withdraw the allotment and make public the Cabinet decision and the government resolution behind it.
It has also asked the authorities to explain why the land is being given without an auction and what legal provision allows an individual to receive such a concession.
Another concern raised by the group is the alleged unauthorised occupation of the plot over the years. It wants the VMC to clarify whether any action has been taken to remove the alleged encroachment and recover applicable penalties or outstanding dues.
With the General Board meeting scheduled for November 18, the land allotment is likely to remain a major point of discussion in Vadodara’s civic politics.
Also Read: 2002 Gujarat Riots: SC Grants Bail To Two Bilkis Bano Case Convicts










